Renting Trouble In Corpus Christi – STR Bans?

Share this story:
Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail

You may like renting a house instead of a hotel on vacation, but the folks who live permanently in those neighborhoods don’t always like it.
Cities across Texas are already locked in huge legal battles over the right of the government to regulate or ban short term rentals.

In Corpus Christi, Texas, the city council could vote to waste more tax money on lawyers. And there are allegations a state judge is breaking ethics rules, throwing her weight around to get her way. Is Corpus Christi city hall RENTING TROUBLE?


SHORT TERM RENTAL

Our thirsty for answers investigation in Corpus Christi has had so many distractions. That nonsensical fake hotel scandal. It cost taxpayers hundreds of thousands of dollars.

We watched the money being flushed down the toilet. And now, in the middle of the runoff, City Council has decided it wants to tackle short-term rentals. So, get out your wallets, folks, because more legal bills, they are a-comin’.

“What’s your name?” said Dee Williams.

“My name is Wayne Dolcefino. What’s your name?”

“It’s none of your business!” said Dee Williams.

I had absolutely no clue who this charming woman was. But our friends in Corpus tell us her name is Dee Dee Williams. She lives one block off of Corpus Christi’s Ocean Drive, the epicenter in the fight over what to do, if anything, about short-term rentals.

Old mansions being redone to use as Airbnbs. I only knew Dee Dee had just tried to block us from questioning the most powerful judge in all of Nueces County.

“Hey judge?” Wayne asks to the Corpus Christi Judge as they walk.

“No, she’s not going to talk. She’s fine,” replies her cohort.

“Well, I’m sure she’s fine.”

Dee Dee Williams shouts, “Leave her alone!”

Wayne only continues to ask the Judge questions as Ms. Williams defends and blocks her like a body guard.

“Hey judge, I’d like to talk to you. Do you think it was appropriate to use your judge’s title in these communications? Don’t- get out of my way! Excuse me! You’re pushing me!” exclaims Wayne.

Dee Dee continues to retaliate and claims, “No, you are pushing me!”

Wayne continues regardless of Dee Dee being in the way. “Your Honor, do you think it was appropriate to use your official position in these communications with the city?”

A 71-year-old woman playing bodyguard for the woman making her getaway. Her name is Missy Medary, Judge Medary. The presiding judge over all of the district courts in Nueces County.

KRIS 6 News reports, “Judge Missy Medary sworn in today for a pretty important statewide assignment.”

Judge Medary is in a unique and very powerful position. She can make life difficult for anyone who appears in any court, including the city of Corpus Christi. Taxpayers have already shelled out hundreds of thousands of dollars in unnecessary legal fees on stupid investigations, lawsuits, conspiracy theories. As a taxpayer, Missy Medary has every right to do what she had just done. Complain to Corpus Christi City Hall.

“I come before you as a homeowner who has been affected by the short-term rentals around me,” states Judge Medary to City Council.

Wayne tells Judge Medary, “I have no issue with you as a homeowner, but what- “

“That’s all I am is a homeowner,” replies Medary.

Medary is a leader in the fight to crack down, or outright ban, short-term rentals in single-family houses. That’s her First Amendment right and notice she said she was there just as a homeowner.

“All I am is a homeowner,” she says.

Look, I get it. I understand someone bought their dream home and all of a sudden, the next-door neighbor has turned it into a rental house that has parties with up to 50 people. I understand why folks in the neighborhood don’t like it.

The neighbors played clips of some of their secret surveillance. Folks standing around outside one of the rentals after a noisy party. A guy walking from the back of a house after apparently relieving himself. This neighbor thinks something more sinister was going on.

“I don’t think that’s what he was doing. I think he walked out to those young ladies to sell drugs,” says a resident of Ocean Drive.

Another neighbor says to city council, “We have hundreds of videos, photos and police reports of what we are enduring because of the city allowing this runway train to wreak havoc in our city.”

“I think those parties that are going on there are going to ruin Ocean Drive, one of the prettiest drives in our country,” says the Ocean Drive resident.

“We host thousands upon thousands upon thousands of guests. Does a party happen every once in a while? Yes. And we go in and we shut it down when we find out about it,” says Chris Munro.

The target of the neighbor’s ire is this guy: Chris Munro. His company is called Coastal Family Homes. They have bought and refurbished more than 30 million dollars worth of property in the city, a lot of it on Ocean Drive, like this house. Judge Medary was one of the neighbors who wanted the city to revoke Munro’s STR permits. The city investigated and said all was legal. But it appears City Hall is now buckling to the never-ending complaints from his wealthy neighbors. The judge is the leader of the pack.

“The intent was to revisit the entire ordinance from allowable denticities to addressing ongoing distances,” states Yvette Wallace.

 The Corpus Christi City Council was being asked to toughen the short-term rental ordinance, limit the number, locations, adding fees to help pay for more enforcement.

“All you have to do is ask yourself one question. Would you want that next door to where your greatest investment is?” says Mayor Paulette Guajardo.

But before the day was done, the mayor and city council would approve the changes but also vote as well for an outright ban of short-term rentals in single-family homes, leading the effort Carolyn Vaughan, Gil Hernandez, familiar names in our Corpus Christi investigations for their financial ties and help they provided to hotelier Ajit David and his partner Raju Bhagat.

“We are going to ruin our state by having these short-term rentals in single family payments. This is a nightmare,” states another Corpus Christi Coucilmember.

That’s a decision that taxpayers will now have to defend in court. It could come back to cost taxpayers millions. Short-term rentals are controversial in every city across Texas. And the Texas Supreme Court is about to decide just how much cities can regulate these places.

The courts have recognized cities’ rights to regulate short-term in some previous cases, but… In Dallas, the city voted to ban them.

The city’s ordinance has remained in legal limbo since it was passed three years ago. So did New Braunfels. This legal battle has been going on now for years.

But Corpus has a bigger problem. They approved short-term rentals four years ago, a set of rules the city manager didn’t enforce. “Banning existing short- term rentals now will trigger a major property rights lawsuit.”

So, it’s the right of a property owner to use their property the way they want, and the rights of a city to protect neighborhoods.

“It seems kind of foolish for the city to change their ordinance now when they could just wait a few months and find out what the higher court is going to say they can and can’t do,” claims Munro.

Just what taxpayers need in Corpus Christi, another lawsuit from a city council that has made it quite clear they don’t know what they’re doing.

“The votes are in, but for most of Corpus Christi City Council candidates, the race isn’t over,” FOX 4 reports.

I bet it’s why incumbents Carolyn Vaughn and Eric Cantu find themselves in runoffs, trying to avoid being thrown off council for what has happened the last two years. It explains, in part, why Gil Hernandez couldn’t beat the mayor on election day, came in second in the mayor’s race. There is now a runoff. Taxpayers got stuck with a $450,000 legal bill. When they paid out Ajit David and his lawyer Doug Allison for what amounted to a fake scandal they created, a failed attempt to oust the mayor of political show, $100,000 more in legal expenses to fight Ajit in court. The city knew that Ajit was pissed off, that his competitors got the same tax breaks he did when they built the new Homewood Suites Hotel by Hilton. Law enforcement dismissed the notion that developers defrauded the city. And this sure looks suspicious.

The very same day Ajit and his lawyer got their money from City Hall, from Council, a political action committee, Corpus Christi United, was formed and then spent tens of thousands of dollars trying to get Gil Hernandez, elected mayor, for all we know they’re still spending. Hernandez had voted to remove the mayor. Voted for their payout, too. Doug Allison and Ajit David are returning the financial favor.

I’m sure you’re not gonna be shocked, but guess who’s in the middle of this fight, too? Yeah, Ajit David. David lives along Ocean Drive, signed the letter complaining about the STRs.

Even Munro states, “Ajit David is a massive hotelier here in Corpus Christi. Ajit David does not want our short-term rentals here because they take away from his business. A lot of the comments we get are, we don’t want to stay in one of Corpus Christi’s shitty hotels.”

But this time, it’s Medary’s conduct that raises the most troubling red flags.

Wayne asks the Judge, “Do you think it was appropriate to use your official position in these communications with the city?”

Under state open records laws, Medary emails to city staff have now been made public.

Wayne tells the Judge, “Well, I’ve seen the emails, Your Honor.”

The evidence is damning that Medary used her judicial position to apply pressure on Corpus Christi City Hall. In her emails to city officials, she would put her name. But then later, in the same email, she put her official judicial title and name.

Was that a reminder of just how powerful she is? Her address? The courthouse. Her phone number? Her government office.

“I think that she’s trying to remind everyone that she is a judge,” recalls Munro about the emails.

And Medary was on the city’s case big time.

Munro continues, “Judge Madary said multiple times in the STR committee, “we have to rewrite this ordinance to ban Christopher Munro’s properties.””

Is that coercion that will benefit the judge personally getting rid of the STRs could improve home values? Did the judge violate ethics rules?

City officials sure felt the pressure. You’re about to hear what they say when they don’t know they’re being recorded. This is Yvette Wallace, the Director of Development Services.

“Person to person, would I say that it is misuse of power? Absolutely. When they send me emails, say, I’m not acting on behalf of my, you know, as myself as the judge, but then signs it as judge material, right? It doesn’t work that way,” Yvette states secretly.

Over a several-month period, Medary and her friends hounded city officials to revoke permits for short-term rentals. There are about 276 STRs in the city, some of them multifamily apartment complexes. They want to target her neighbor, Chris Munro. The city investigated but said they found nothing to support the complaints.

Critics spoke at council about just this one business but the city staff told a different story if its an abuse of power why did the city appoint Missy Medary to the committee that was rewriting the STR ordinance.

“She just wanted us to make it all stop when we said, we can’t, right? You are operating within the ordinance, so it’s perfectly legal. The behavior itself is, it’s – yeah, it’s honestly a misuse of power,” Yvette continues.

Another judge, Bobby Galvan, is also involved in the neighborhood fight. He would have to be recused in a lawsuit, I bet. Probably all Corpus judges will.

The conflicts of interest are obvious. As Chris Munro prepares for an expensive legal battle to protect his property.

“One of the reasons why we had to seek outside counsel outside of Nueces County was because no attorney would touch it. Every attorney we spoke with was fearful to go up against Judge Medary. They all said, I either have cases before her or I could have cases for her court, I’m not willing to touch this,” recalls Chris Munro.

The city’s already facing a multi-million-dollar lawsuit from the Homewood Suites developers. Ajit David’s political allies got their two million tax incentive killed. They’ll probably get it back.

Ajit’s control of council has been on display for the entire year we’ve been in Corpus. When he sued Corpus Christi taxpayers, it was Judge Medary who assigned the case to Judge Watts. She took the case despite a lifelong friendship with Ajit David’s lawyer, Doug Allison. Allison was the lawyer in the judge’s divorce.

Councilman Hernandez continues to hide his communications with Ajit David. It’s one of the big reasons we’ve had to sue the city. Guess it pays to be a big, powerful judge.

On February 13th, the city sent an email to Munro, granting a permit for a house at 5445 Ocean Drive. Look at the time, 4:17 in the afternoon. Four hours later, Medary emails that she had been notified by the city.

How do I get that kind of response? I’ve been fighting for months for records!

“I think that Ajit controls the actions that they do and I think that Ajit doesn’t want Short-Term rentals and if Judge Medary doesn’t want short term rentals, I think that those individuals are going to vote to not have Short-Term rentals in Corpus Christi,” said Chris Munro.

The judge could have been nice and rolled down her window to keep our one-sided conversation going, but she didn’t defend herself and I’ve gotten used to asking important questions to car windows.

Back to the email conversation, Wayne reminds the Judge through her car window, “I’ve seen the emails, Your Honor.”

Madary and some of her neighbors call Chris Munro a bad actor. Behind the scenes, city officials are praising him. The city has started fining Munro, revoking one of his permits he thinks it’s Medary and Ajit David pulling the strings.

Do you think it’s appropriate in a courthouse that’s already questioned because of its conflicts of interest?

The judge took off, but my new friend Dee Dee stayed behind to claim that I “assaulted” her.

Dee Dee: “You have no right!”

Wayne: “I got every right to ask any question I want, mam.”

Dee Dee Willams:“She asked you to leave her alone.”

Wayne: “I don’t care.”

Dee Dee: “And you pushed me!”

Wayne:“You were pushing me, mam.”

Dee Dee Willams: “No I did not! You pushed me right here!” and motions to her stomach.

Wayne: “Alright.”

Fools.

Dee Dee then yells, “You want me to put my elbow in your stomach?”

Wayne’s only response, “Go ahead darling, you just did.”

Keep up with us on social media:
Facebooktwitterlinkedinrssyoutubeinstagram